Idea KilnIdea Kiln
All tools·Free Tool·For Startup Founders

Score Your Startup Idea in 5 Minutes.

Evaluate your idea across 10 critical criteria used by top investors. Get an overall score, a radar chart, and actionable recommendations — completely free.

10Scoring criteria
YesRadar chart
FreeNo sign-up
About

What the Validator scores

Most founders validate their startup idea by asking friends and family — who almost always say "great idea!" This tool replaces that biased feedback with a structured evaluation across 10 criteria that actually predict startup success. Each criterion is scored 1–5 based on your honest answers to diagnostic questions, then combined into a weighted overall Idea Score from 0 to 100.

The criteria cover the full spectrum of what makes a startup viable: from whether you're solving a real, frequent problem (Problem Clarity) to whether you can actually reach and acquire customers (Distribution and Customer Accessibility). High-weight criteria like Market Size, Monetization, and Problem Clarity have the most impact on your score because they're the strongest predictors of long-term success.

How it works

Three steps to your score

01

Describe Your Idea

Enter your idea name, a one-liner description, your industry, and current stage. This context frames the scoring for your specific concept.

02

Answer 10 Criteria

Evaluate your idea one criterion at a time. Each screen asks 2–4 targeted questions about a specific dimension — from market size to distribution strategy.

03

Get Your Score

See your Idea Score (0–100), a radar chart of all 10 dimensions, strengths, red flags, and prioritized action items to improve your weakest areas.

The 10 criteria

What makes a strong startup idea?

Understanding what each criterion measures helps you answer honestly and interpret your results accurately.

12
weight

Problem Clarity

Can you articulate the problem in one sentence? Do real people experience it frequently? The best startups solve painful, recurring problems. Vague problem statements are the #1 reason ideas fail early.

12
weight

Market Size

Is the addressable market large enough to build a meaningful business? A brilliant solution to a problem only 100 people have won't sustain a company. Look for markets above $100M TAM with growth trends.

10
weight

Competition

Healthy competition validates demand. No competitors can mean no market. What matters is whether you can articulate a clear advantage for a specific segment — not whether competition exists.

12
weight

Monetization

Do you have a clear path to revenue? Subscription models score highest because of predictable recurring revenue. The key question: have you validated that real customers will actually pay?

10
weight

Unfair Advantage

What do you have that a well-funded competitor can't easily replicate? Proprietary technology, unique data, deep domain expertise, or an existing audience all count. This is your moat.

8
weight

Timing

Why now? New technology, regulatory shifts, or behavior changes create windows of opportunity. Many great ideas failed because they were too early. Timing is often the difference between success and 'ahead of its time.'

10
weight

Founder-Market Fit

Do you have industry experience, domain expertise, or relationships with potential customers? Founders who deeply understand their market move faster, make better decisions, and earn customer trust.

10
weight

Distribution

How will you reach your first 100 customers? Having an existing audience, a clear channel strategy, or organic acquisition potential is critical. Paid ads alone are rarely sustainable for early-stage startups.

8
weight

Scalability

Can your business serve 100x more customers without 100x more resources? Digital products and SaaS models score highest here. Services that require proportional headcount growth face scaling limits.

8
weight

Customer Accessibility

How easy is it to find, reach, and convert your target customer? If your ideal customer is hard to identify or reach, acquisition costs will eat into your margins. Direct customer conversations validate this criterion.

FAQ

Frequently asked.

Next steps

Build something people want.

Share your startup on IdeaKiln and get visibility, feedback, and support from a community of builders and indie hackers.

Startup Idea Validator: Score Your Idea Free | Idea Kiln